I often get to the end of a day and wonder what I actually achieved. I’ve been busy, and I could give you a perfectly respectable account of the things I did. What I’m less sure about is whether any of them mattered.
I recognise the pattern from my working life, when many days were taken up with a never-ending series of things that seemed important at the time. Looking back, probably only a few of them were. The really important work often only bubbled to the surface when the working day was over, which left me with a choice: attend to it at home that evening, or risk watching it slide to the back of the queue again tomorrow.
The evening became the time for the work the day was supposed to accommodate. There is something fairly wrong with that arrangement, however familiar it sounds.
An article by Kelsey Pelzer in Parade brought this back to me. She describes spending ten days trying a question drawn from Marcus Aurelius: “Is this necessary?” I haven’t done her experiment. What interests me is the pause the question requires, before the next apparently important thing gets my attention.
In Book 4, passage 24 of Meditations, Marcus tells himself to question unnecessary actions and thoughts. He also qualifies the advice to do less: we still have to do what reason and our nature as social beings require. He isn’t offering permission to abandon our responsibilities.
That qualification makes the question more useful, because helping somebody can take an afternoon and leave nothing you can cross off a list. A difficult conversation might deserve more time than everything else on the calendar. Necessary doesn’t have to mean quick or measurable.
The problem I recognise is how easily something gets my attention simply because it has arrived. Once I’m dealing with it, it feels like work, and once I’ve finished it, I have the satisfaction of having dealt with it. Meanwhile, the thing that needs sustained thought is still waiting.
I know this problem particularly well from programming. To work effectively on a program, I need to hold a mental model of it in my head. In my experience, getting that model loaded can take ten or fifteen minutes, sometimes longer. Once I’m working with it, I’m “in the flow”, but that concentration is fragile. A “this’ll just take a minute” question can break it, and afterwards I have to rebuild the model before I can get on with the work.
From the other person’s side, it was a quick question. From mine, it could cost another fifteen minutes just to get back to where I was. If you’re about to interrupt a programmer, it’s worth asking whether you really need the answer right now, or whether it can wait.
I think that’s where “Is this necessary?” earns its place, on both sides of the interruption. The question interrupts the assumption that whatever I’m doing deserves the time I’m giving it, or the time I’m asking somebody else to give it. Sometimes the answer will be yes. Sometimes it will be that it needs doing, but it can wait until the more important work is finished.
Marcus includes thoughts in the same passage, which is an uncomfortable addition. You can stop answering requests and still spend the hour mentally rehearsing them. Imagine returning to a conversation, composing a better reply long after it has ended. At some point, you need to decide whether there’s anything left to do about it. Further thought needs a reason too.
I don’t want to turn this into another test I can fail at the end of the day. An afternoon spent reading or talking to somebody doesn’t need a business case. Rest is allowed, and the fact that something gives pleasure is a perfectly good reason to choose it. The distinction I’m interested in is whether I chose where my attention went, or simply followed the next thing that asked for it.
I still find myself asking what I achieved when the day is over. I’d like to get better at asking what deserves my time while there’s still some of the day left.
Sources:
Kelsey Pelzer’s Parade article prompted this reflection. The philosophical passage is Marcus Aurelius, Meditations, Book 4, passage 24 (George Long translation).


